Судьи WCCI 2016-18

English page

Харольд ван дер Хейден:
«Кроме прочих художественных достоинств (темы / идеи), на мой взгляд, хороший этюд должен содержать сюрприз или что-нибудь, что заставит нас улыбнуться.».
Петер Дьярмати:
«Я люблю тактические этюды».
«Этюд должен быть под силу решателю».
Стеффен Нильсен:
«Точность и экономия не делают окончание этюдом. Работа шахматных композиторов не в демонстрации сложности шахмат».
Мартин Мински:
«Я не люблю компьютерные этюды с большим количеством аналитических вариантов».
Арпад Рус:
«Мне очень не нравится, когда кто-то раздувает решение дуальными вариантами и попытками. Историю должно рассказывать само реальное решение, а для аналитических вариантов у нас есть компьютер».
19 комментариев
Межтекстовые Отзывы
Посмотреть все комментарии
Árpád Rusz
Árpád Rusz
4 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

Sergiy, I think you have a point regarding me and P. Gyarmati being a judge at the same time. Although I still represent Romania in the FIDE, I am also Hungarian (I possess both citizenships). By the way, I didn’t know that Gyarmati is also an appointed judge until a couple days ago. If somebody officially complains, I am ready to step back.

Владислав Тарасюк
Владислав Тарасюк
4 лет назад

Сергей, ты задал не пару вопросов, а три. Пиши правильно и будь повнимательнее.

Martin Minski
Martin Minski
4 лет назад

Sergiy, I’m a judge because I was asked and agreed. I will do this job very conscientiously, but I give up if someone else wants to do it. Actually, it’s just a lot of work and later you will be criticized by many composers.

It is not a dream job. Tell me, who should do it for me, then I give up immediately

Martin Minski
Martin Minski
4 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

You know very well that no Russians and no Ukrainians were taken this time as judges to avoid conflicts. Tell me some names of competent judges that are missing. I think there are not so many good study judges with experience for this job.

Martin Minski
Martin Minski
4 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

Yes, you are right. It was not successively asked the 15 best. I may have been asked first and I should suggest more judges. I also suggested Oleg and you. But the answer was this time no Russians and no Ukrainians. I suggested Nielsen, Rusz and Gyarmati because I think they are competent. Now Costeff was added, which I like. Who wants to do this job? That’s just a lot of work. Who should do this job? Jasik has little experience, I think.

Why should not I be judge twice? Where is the problem?

Steffen Nielsen
Steffen Nielsen
4 лет назад

In the moremovers section there are both a Russian and an Ukrainian judge. And one Ukrainian in the retro section. So I guess exceptions could have been made.

Keith
Keith
4 лет назад

The main purpose of a study is to move. Either by its beauty, by its tactics, or by its complexity provided it is economic and paradoxical. Of course, the analytical lines must not be too numerous  and, if in addition, they were troublesome, they could disrupt an overworked judge.

AA
AA
3 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

I am sure you didn’t mean it, but the fact is that the caricature has a strong smell of antisemitism.

Kindly remove it.

Martin Minski
Martin Minski
3 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

Please, Sergiy, take out the photo.
We want to continue arguing about the matter without political interpretations that could hurt others. Gady is a man of honor. I know him personally.

Martin Minski
Martin Minski
3 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

If I understand you correctly, you did not want to provoke an anti-Semitic interpretation in any way.

It isn’t?

Martin Minski
Martin Minski
3 лет назад

Harold van der Heijden is the new judge.