Michal Hlinka-65

ЮК Михал Глинка-65 проводился в двух разделах.

Раздел А. Этюды на выигрыш

Раздел В. Этюды с патом в финале
Подписаться
Уведомить о
40 комментариев
Межтекстовые Отзывы
Посмотреть все комментарии
Перваков
5 лет назад

Решил Мартина поддержать, чтоб его не одного убивали))

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

Great! I always wanted to die for a study. 🙂

Oleg is innocent. I blackmailed him with Polish vodka. 🙂

The scheme is inspired from Oleg’s wonderful 1st prize in EG-50 AT 2016. It comes out when an amateur like me composes …

By the way, I have already received congratulations for this study.
But of course also ridicule, e.g.
“This is a task … ‘All pieces (7) from the initial position of a study are under attack.’ ;)”

I can live with the reviews.
To the critics I encourage them to compose a study with 3 pinned rook stalemates. You will notice, it is not so easy.

Martin Minski
5 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

Oleg is really innocent in this case.
I implemented this idea alone, but I used Oleg’s mechanism.
That’s why I offered him co-authorship.
He tried to eliminate the obvious weaknesses of the study, but failed.
I thought that Michal Hlinka, the jubilee, would like this idea.
That is perhaps the main thing in this case.

Oleg showed 3 pin stalemates with pinned knight with technically
almost perfect realization.
I showed 3 pin stalemates with pinnend bishop at 2018 Olympics
with a different mechanism.
It is absolutely legitimate for me to show a 3 pin stalemates
with pinned rook.
It is a new task.
That is allowed!

Перваков
5 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

I am not a coward. At the time of Pushkin I would challenge you to a duel for such words, Sergey!))

My opinion: any task has to have a chance to see it. You open the new horizons, and your followers will improve them!

Перваков
5 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

As a real study is bad but as a task is very good!
Try to compose Babson task in study! I try to realize it nearly 20 years… In Album only 3/4 but wrong. But they in Album!))

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

I see there are some dislikes from composers who participated in the tournament
and did not appear in the award.

I respect Sergiy Didukh. He does not hide cowardly behind his dislike and is silent, but expresses his honest opinion, even though he writes a lot of nonsense.

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

Congratulations to Geir Sune for the successful presentation of double-pin stalemate with promoted pinned pieces!

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

The best thing about the 1st prize in win section A seems to be
the name of the composer.
Who can explain the wonderful in this study?

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

Sergiy, I’m listening to your comments.
You are the pope!

Without irony:
I like the little study of Mario Garcia and
I am glad that he now knows what an ideal stalemate is.

Martin Minski
5 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

I had guessed that it must be anticipated.

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

Sergiy, I have learned from you that the economics of the final scene is more important than avoiding bad exchange in the play. Now you solemnly present a study with good play, but with some static pieces and bad economics in the stalemate picture (in contrast to Geir Sune’s study). That is a contradiction!

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

I do not know what you want to explain to me.
You criticize the obvious weaknesses of a study
and show me another study with other weaknesses.
Such a task is a real technical challenge.
Geir Sune wants to continue trying to find a better version.
He told me that Richard Becker has already showed
it with two pinned underpromoted knights.
I think it is legitimate to publish studies with
small flaws but with attractive ideas.
This may help to find the optimal scheme someday.

We are allowed to compose everything we want.
There is no “wrong” idea! It is a free world.

Your criticism is exceptionally sharp here.
I dont understand this.
Please show your sophisticated technique and compose this task better!

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

When I look at a study award,
I am particularly interested in the ideas of the new compositions,
regardless of the technical perfection.
Yes, I immediately noticed the study by Geir Sune,
even though I saw the many exchanges.

There are studies that seem technically perfect,
but where I can not see a real idea.
I forgot these studies after a week.

Martin Minski
5 лет назад

Black and white are just the chess pieces. You will understand that when you are older.

Перваков
5 лет назад
Ответ на  Didukh

OK, Sergey, one question. What do you show us by your horror study 1-5 prize from Tarasiuk?

Перваков
5 лет назад

And I answer by yourself: you want to congratulate Vladislav. And I want to congratulate (with Martin) Michal!
Draw! 1-1.